News USA

California’s Tastries Bakery Agrees to Pay $12,000 in Case Over Refusal to Sell a Wedding Cake to a Same-Sex Couple

On November 16, the California Civil Rights Department announced a settlement with Tastries, a bakery in Bakersfield. The bakery refused to sell Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio a cake for their wedding in 2017. The parties submitted the proposed consent decree to a Kern County court for approval.

Under the agreement, the bakery would pay the couple $8,000 and the department $4,000 toward legal costs. If Tastries offers cakes in standard designs or other non-customized products, it agrees to sell them on equal terms regardless of sexual orientation or other legally protected characteristics. The five-year agreement also calls for annual staff training and reports to the department.

The couple chose a plain white, three-tiered cake without lettering based on a display model. Tastries owner Cathy Miller refused the order when she learned that the cake was for a wedding between two women. Miller invoked the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, arguing that making wedding cakes was an expression of her religious beliefs.

The trial court sided with the bakery in 2022. In 2025, a California appeals court overturned that ruling. It found that the refusal amounted to discrimination based on sexual orientation and that selling a cake in the selected design would not compel the bakery to express a view about the wedding. The California and U.S. supreme courts declined to review the case.

Related materials

Latest news

Lebanese Daily Annahar Calls for Repeal of Article 534, Used to Prosecute Same-Sex Relations U.S. Rules Keep Transgender and Nonbinary Australian Sailors From Starting AUKUS Submarine Training Dating App Grindr Launches AI-Powered Edge Subscription. It Costs $120 a Month in the U.S.